Trying to Stop the Brain Drain in South Africa

From the Archives

Previously filed under: Africa, Health
South Africa's health department takes drastic measures to stop the emigration of skilled health care workers.
Photo Credit: Bob Newell/Mercy Corps
By 2009, all public health professionals in South Africa will see a substantial increase in pay. Photo Credit: Bob Newell/Mercy Corps
A groundbreaking move by South Africa's health department could see nurses being paid at least 20 percent more, becoming the first beneficiaries of a plan to attract more healthcare students and keep homegrown skills home with higher salaries.

After the recent month-long strike by public servants, Health Minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang announced an across-the-board increase of at least 20 percent for public nurses, as well as improved medical coverage and housing subsidies.

As part of this new "occupation specific dispensation" system, doctors, dentists, pharmacists and emergency care workers would move to a similar pay system next year, while all other public health professionals would see substantial increases by 2009.

The recent industrial action - South Africa's longest public service strike - ended on 28 June, but not before bringing the country to its knees: health workers, teachers and government employees took to the streets in protest; state hospitals were forced to transfer patients to private facilities and discharge all non-critical cases.1

A groundbreaking move by South Africa's health department could see nurses being paid at least 20 percent more.
In South Africa it is illegal for members of essential services, such as the police and medical personnel, to strike. Tension mounted when government countered the unions' initial demand of a 12 percent hike with an offer of only 6 percent; a mutually agreed 7.5 percent increase brought the strike to an end.

A newly qualified professional nurse would now enter the public health sector at a salary of R96,750 per year (about US$13,900), which is R17,343 (about $2,500) more than that person would have received before July 2007," Tshabalala-Msimang said.

While all nurses will receive an increase of at least 20 percent, they will also have additional opportunities. "Nurses will now have an opportunity to progress to higher salary levels, based on performance, education and accumulation of skills," she said.

Pierre Uys, provincial health minister for the Western Cape Province said nurse educators had received special attention in the new system and would receive R159,000 (about $22,800) annually, in an effort to increase the country's capacity.

"Previously, nurse educators earned a salary parallel to that of professional nurses, which meant it was always very difficult to attract them to the field," Uys said. "We now hope to attract a small but qualified group of people."

According to the South African Nurses Council, the country produces approximately 2,500 nurses per year, but a 2006 study by the Center for Global Development found that more than 4,844 were working overseas.2 At least 12,207 South African health workers in total - including an estimated 21 percent of doctors produced in the country - were practicing abroad in 2006.

The health department continues to identify "brain drain", or the emigration of skilled health workers, as a continuing trend.

The South African health department continues to identify "brain drain", or the emigration of skilled health workers, as a continuing trend.
While South African rands may still not compete with British pounds, Uys said the new increase would at least put public health salaries on a par with the private sector in South Africa.

Although the details were still being finalised in talks between the government and health worker unions, such as the National Education, Health and Allied Workers Union (NEHAWU)3 and the Health and Other Service Personnel Trade Union of SA (Hospersa)4, union officials were pleased.

"Negotiations are still continuing, we are still working out the translation keys between the new and old salary structures to determine where everyone will be but, so far, we're happy," said Rifos Mahlake, a Hospersa negotiator.

The talks are expected to conclude by 31 August - overshooting the original 31 July deadline by a month - said James Cornwall, chief negotiator for the public health and social development sectors, but nurses would still receive the increase retroactively from 1 July.

Footnotes:

1 IRINnews.org - South Africa's longest public service strike

2 Centre for Global Development

3 National Education, Health and Allied Workers Union

4 Health and Other Service Personnel Trade Union of SA




Reprinted with permission from IRINnews.org.©2007 IRIN This article does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations or its agencies.

To read another Global Envision article about skilled labor migration, see Where Brain Drains Lead.



Return to top

Comments

There are pros and cons to "brain drain", just as there is to outsourcing. Countries that are experiencing brain drain need to find a way to persuade their intellectuals to stay and find partnerships with intellectuals in developed countries.

It is a huge hit and promising start which I would be following to see the impacts it has made.Many researchers say that low salries, shortage of supplies and work overload are said tobe unsatisfactory reasons for brain-drain. Provided that this measure was taken based up on an evidence, the I'm optimistic of the outcomes. In any case recognizing and acknowledging the dealings health professionals face is the positive side of it. I hope other sectors too have agreed!
Behailu M (Ethiopia,Ireland)

in London

Brain Brain: SOUTH AFRICAN NURSES

I'M A PROUD SOUTH AFRICAN CURRENTLY RESIDING IN THE UNITED KINGDOM. MY WIVE IS WORKING AS A CARER HERE IN LONDON. MY WIVE IS WORKING 13 HOURS/7DAYS A WEEK ITS REALLY EFFECTING OUR MARRIAGE AND FAMILY LIFE. SHE DON'T CARE ABOUT US, THE ONLY THING ON HER MIND IS £. MY WIFE BETRAYED RSA WHO GAVE HER FREE EDUCATION AND HELP HER GET TO WHERE SHE IS TODAY. TODAY SHE THINKS THAT SHE IS BETTER THEN HER FELLOW S.AFRICANS. THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD PASS A LAW TO CURB NURSES TO GO TO ANOTHER COUNTRY.

in AFRICA

Brain Brain: SOUTH AFRICAN NURSES

:-(


Stories We're Watching

As Growth Slows, India Awakens to Need for Foreign Investment

International Herald Tribune - Wed, 02/08/2012 - 08:26
India’s central bank and economic analysts predict that growth will fall sharply to 7 percent this fiscal year and remain sluggish.

Social responsibility and a new world order

Washington Post - Innovations - Tue, 02/07/2012 - 07:56
Just before the New Year, the London-based Center for Economics and Business Research announced that Brazil had overtaken the United Kingdom as the world’s sixth largest economy. Furthermore, it predicted that by 2020, India and Russia will also have overtaken all the European economic powers.

Aid for trade policy rears its ugly head

The Guardian's Poverty Matters - Mon, 02/06/2012 - 01:41
The UK government's dismay at not being granted the contract for Typhoon fighter jets in India is an indication that its controversial aid for trade policy is still very much alive.

Liberia's battle to put the lights back on

The Guardian's Poverty Matters - Sun, 02/05/2012 - 23:00
Ellen Johnson Sirleaf has set ambitious targets to restore the country's electricity supply. But will it meet them by 2015?

As Africa's consumers rise, so does inequality

Yale Global Online - Fri, 02/03/2012 - 10:17
Kenya struggles to spread the wealth from rapid growth.

Recent comments

Countries

An initiative of Mercy Corps
“You must be the change
you wish to see in the world”
Mahatma Gandhi
Learn more about Mercy Corps >

Efficiency

Over the last five years, more than 89% of Mercy Corps' resources have been allocated directly to programs

Excellence

America's premier charity evaluator gives Mercy Corps four stars in organizational efficiency. Click here to learn more.

High Value

Every dollar you donate to Mercy Corps helps us secure $11.16 in donated food and other critical supplies.

Mercy Corps — Dept. W — 45 SW Ankeny — Portland, OR 97204
All original content Copyright © 2009 Mercy Corps. Quoted and linked content is property of the creator(s). Mercy Corps will not sell, rent or trade your personal information.