Culture - Unit on Religion and Globalization
From the Archives
Posted on November 2, 2005
Previously filed under: Lesson Plans
 |
For a copy of this Lesson Plan in Microsoft Word click here.
Introduction
This unit focuses on religious perspectives about globalization. In the introductory discussion, students will discuss the role of values in shaping perspectives about globalization, through consideration of an article on globalization written by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and a Globalizaton101.org "Ask the Experts" interview. Then, students will consider how religious values generally may conflict with both economic and cultural globalization. Next, they will learn about the specific responses to globalization of certain religions. Finally, they will learn about how some religions have benefited from globalization.
NOTE:
Since this unit covers religion, it may not be appropriate for public schools. We advise that teachers exercise careful judgment in discussing these matters. Avoid judgments. Keep discussions to statements of fact, and away from the discussing the validity of particular religious claims. Avoid stereotyping. Emphasize that religions are not monolithic, and that individuals of the same faith often disagree on important details. Make students aware of the need for sensitivity toward religious traditions and the obstacle that stereotyping presents for academic inquiry in comparative religion.
Student Objectives
| Unit Objectives | Your State Standard |
|---|---|
|
Click here for updated State Standards |
Resources
Required
- Globalization101.org video of the interview with Ira Rifkin, "Spiritual Perspectives on Globalization" (watch video)
- Globalization101.org, Unit on Culture and Globalization
- Paper from the International Monetary Fund (IMF): "Globalization: Threat or Opportunity"
Suggested
- Speech of Cardinal Francis George to the the "Congreso Americano Misionero" in Paraná Argentina, "Globalization: Challenges to the Church's Mission"
- Article from the Bahá'í International Community, "The Prosperity of Humankind"
- Weekly column on business ethics by Rabbi Dr. Asher Meir, "The Jewish Ethicist: The Risks and Benefits of a Worldwide Marketplace"
- Article from the World Council of Churches: "Lead Us Not Into Temptation: Churches Response to the Policies of International Financial Institutions"
- David Frawley, "The Hindu Response to Globalization", in Hinduism and the Clash of Civilizations
- Article by Chandra Muzaffar, "Globalization and Religion"
- Article by James Kurth, "Religion and Globalization"
- Article by Alfred Bloom, "Globalization and Buddhism"
- Article by David Loy, "Religion and the Market"
- Article by Philip Jenkins, "The Next Christianity"
- Article by Vinay Lal, "Reflections on the Indian Diaspora"
Time Required
4-5 classes
Procedure
Introductory Discussion—Values and Globalization (2 class periods)
- Begin a discussion of religious perspective on globalization by discussing the role of religion generally in shaping the values, beliefs, and policies of both societies and individuals. Note that religious influences can be conscious and unconscious, overtime merge into broader cultural values, and are often more influential in non-Western, traditional societies than in the more secular West.
- Have students watch the Globalization101.org Ask the Experts interview with Ira Rifkin Spiritual Perspectives on Globalization" (watch video on Windows Media or Real Player). Based on the comments in the video, discuss why the students think religion might be important in shaping societies' and individuals' perspectives on globalization.
- Next, describe briefly what the International Monetary Fund is and its role in globalization, based on the Globalization101.org Issue Brief on "What is the IMF? and What is the World Bank?" Then have students read the IMF paper, "Globalization: Threat or Opportunity".
- Ask students to identify the values that underlie the IMF's generally positive view of globalization. For example, ask them if free markets are values-free, or do they carry implied values expressed through lifestyle choices? What values are inherent in a consumerist orientation? Does globalization prioritize the belief in the efficiency of free markets over social, cultural, and environmental concerns? Ask students to think of any criticisms they have of the values of the IMF.
- Then, discuss why the values of some religions may conflict with some of the values underlying the IMF's view of globalization. Some issues to consider are the following: How do values associated with a high degree of personal freedom conflict with the values associated with communal responsibility? How do values that stress individual choice challenge religious values? Does consumerism contradict religious values?
- Finally, have students read the section on pop culture in the Globalization101.com Issue Brief on Culture. Discuss how international media spread Western consumer preferences to local cultures via advertising and a focus on "pop culture." How might this conflict with religiously derived values in more traditional societies?
Religions' Various Perspectives on Globalization (2-3 class periods)
- Have students read some of the articles on various religious traditions and their approaches to globalization listed above. You may also assign individual students to read single articles and be prepared to discuss them in class, rather than assigning all students to read all the articles.
- Lead the students in a discussion of the specific approaches of various religions to globalization. Suggested ways to do so include the following:
- Contrast the core teachings of the Abrahamic traditions—Christianity, Islam and Judaism—as presented by Cardinal George, Rabbi Meir, and Chandra Muzaffar, with the Buddhist perspective presented by David Loy and Alfred Bloom.
- Discuss James Kurth's equating of economic and cultural globalization with Calvinist Protestantism, primarily as it developed in the United States.
- Discuss the "social justice" Protestant perspective toward globalized free-markets presented in the World Council of Churches' article. How does it compare to the Catholic perspective on globalization as explained by Cardinal George?
- What is it about the values implied by cultural globalization that are offensive to traditional Muslims (refer to James Kurth and Chandra Muzaffar)?
- As shown in the article, "The Prosperity of Humankind", the Baha'i Faith believes in the eventual unity of all of humanity. How does that fit in with the growth in influence of multinational corporations?
- Contrast the core teachings of the Abrahamic traditions—Christianity, Islam and Judaism—as presented by Cardinal George, Rabbi Meir, and Chandra Muzaffar, with the Buddhist perspective presented by David Loy and Alfred Bloom.
- Have students read the articles on "global Christianity" and the Indian diaspora. Discuss how religions have spread as a result of globalization, ranging from the spread of Christianity by European explorers to the contemporary spread via immigration of Buddhism, Hinduism, and Islam in the West.
Concluding Assignment
- In order to assess students' assimilation of the material, assign them to answer the following essay question: "Is religion a force for opposition to globalization or is it a force for alternative views of globalization?" Make specific references to the beliefs of at least three of the religions we have studied.
For a copy of this Lesson Plan in Microsoft Word click here
Contributed by Center for Strategic & International Studies (CSIS) and Globalization101.org.
Back to main curriculum page.
Return to top
Bookmark/Search this post with
Digg
Facebook
Google Buzz
LinkedIn
StumbleUpon
Twitter
Printer-friendly version
Recent comments
on GOMANGO! A simple solution to save Haiti's leading fruit
on Groups claim World Bank aids land grabs
on Is Foreign Aid Helping Or Hurting Africa?
on More than an argument, land conflicts stall economic growth
on Honduras envisions a Caribbean Hong Kong, but 'charter city' plan meets criticism