Disruptive sanitation: Can 3-wheeled carts and better septic tanks clean up Jakarta?

Value Chains

Disruptive sanitation: Can 3-wheeled carts and better septic tanks clean up Jakarta?

An improved sanitation system allows private sanitation companies to access new customers in narrow urban slums, where some of the 94 million Indonesians live without access to such services. Photo: Mercy Corps
An improved sanitation system allows private sanitation companies to access new customers in narrow urban slums, where some of the 94 million Indonesians live without access to such services. Photo: Mercy Corps

This article was republished by The Christian Science Monitor.

In Jakarta, Indonesia, an international aid nonprofit is getting into some dirty business: the sanitation industry.

By all statistical accounts, the United Nations' Millennium Development Goal of halving the world’s population without access to sanitation services is failing. Some estimate the world won't reach that goal until 2049—34 years late.

For many of the world’s poorest, access to clean sanitation—like toilets and hand washing stations—remains a luxury. Annually, 50,000 Indonesians die as a result of poor sanitation; one person every 10 minutes.

The gravity of this problem, combined with the failures of previous efforts to solve it, led Mercy Corps’s Indonesia team to author a public health project in Jakarta with a nontraditional approach. Instead of simply funding a project to build latrines in Jakarta’s slums, they take a market development approach that will strengthen the value chain of Jakarta’s private sanitation services industry, utilize new technology to enable sanitation companies access previously unreachable people, and turn those people into customers.

Basically, they want to fundamentally change the sanitation industry in Jakarta.

A Mercy Corps project titled PUSH (Program of Urban Sanitation and Hygiene Promotion) undertook a market analysis of Jakarta’s sanitation industry. Funded by the Suez Environment Foundation, the project found a massive untapped market of potential customers in urban Indonesia. Around 94 million Indonesians live without access to sanitation services, and 22 million people—more than two and a half times the population of New York City—have to pay for the use of communal latrines. This incredible number of people, who live mostly in urban slums, have long been overlooked by traditional markets under the assumption that they cannot afford sanitation services.

It became clear that improvements in this system could lower prices, reach more customers and, through marketing and education, encourage more Indonesians to value and pay for improved sanitation services.

To include more people in the market, costs had to fall and products had to specialize. By this time the PUSH initiative had ended and a new Mercy Corps program called RW Siaga++ (“neighborhood alert” in Bahasa Indonesia) began to take over the design and development phase. Funded by Coca-Cola, the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), and in coordination with the local Ministry of Health, the project designed two specialized products that helped increase access to the unmet sanitation market:

The Kedoteng sludge cart doing its dirty job. Photo: Jen Dillan/Mercy Corps
The Kedoteng sludge cart doing its dirty job. Photo: Jen Dillan/Mercy Corps

Specialized products:
1. Custom Sludge Cart: Innumerable inhabitants of Jakarta’s urban slums are considered unreachable by modern sludge removal techniques because they live down narrow pathways where large sludge removal trucks cannot pass. RW Siaga++ designed a custom-made, three-wheeled sludge cart, called Kedoteng, equipped with a mini-sludge removal tank and a pump that can access latrines up to 50 meters away. (See video below)

2. Improved Septic Tanks: A custom, specially-designed septic tank made from locally available materials was designed to meet the needs of up to five people. The tank requires limited ground space, has a built in bio-filter that separates and cleans the refuse without the use of chemicals, and only requires de-sludging of fecal waste once every two years.

By sharing these innovations with the private sector, PUSH showed that the size of the potential sanitation services market had grown exponentially, simply by making new clients physically accessible.

The Kedoteng three-wheeled cart is able to maneuver tiny alleys to reach families living in even the most crowded slums, unlike large trucks that traditionally do the work. Photo: Rae Lyon/Mercy Corps
The Kedoteng three-wheeled cart is able to maneuver tiny alleys to reach families living in even the most crowded slums, unlike large trucks that traditionally do the work. Photo: Rae Lyon/Mercy Corps

Demand-side economics:
While working to bring supply costs down, the team recognized the other side of the market equation—demand—needed attention as well. Taking a cue from the for-profit world, Mercy Corps built some buzz about the innovations by launching a marketing campaign to educate consumers about the importance of sanitation. The campaign included radio and billboard ads, to full-color comic books and school bags for children. They even hired a well-known comedian to talk up better sanitation systems.

To date, the project has surpassed many of its original objectives, having already increased access to over 9,000 individuals in 1,800 households. The project is not only achieving its own objectives but also having multiplier effects: Jakarta’s District Health Offices have replicated some of the educational aspects of the project, and the project’s authors note that community and local government participation in the project has been one of its biggest successes. And the project attracted the attention of the Louise H. and David S. Ingalls Foundation, which is supporting work to reduce the cost of building home-based systems.

Challenges

Mercy Corps found that even with the sanitation market model in place, there is lot of work left to do. Consolidating services and improving the supply chain has lowered costs significantly but installation still costs the target demographic between 150 to 250 percent of a month's income. To address this, Mercy Corps Indonesia has been working with microfinance institutions to let customers spread the costs of their sanitation systems over 20 months, allowing families to pay for their new, private latrines with the savings they would otherwise spend on communal latrine access.

Still, the cost of materials to create the septic tanks and carts fluctuates, making it challenging to keep prices consistently low. Microfinance institutions are interested in staying involved, but aren't yet convinced that the sanitation market is a priority worth investing their own resources. Private sanitation companies have also been slow to refine their models in response to changing consumer demands.

The project’s ambitions are huge: it hopes to tip the scales by introducing lower-priced products, facilitating the entry of the private sector, and improving awareness of the necessity and affordability of sanitation services. If ultimately successful, millions of Jakarta’s poorest residents will have access to microloans to pay for better latrines and sludge removal, which will keep them healthier and leave more cash in their pockets in the long-run.

Despite—and perhaps because of—the challenges that lay ahead, this idea is worth following. By adding value to the demand and supply side of the sanitation industry, Mercy Corps is proposing a sustainable and mutually-beneficial solution that addresses one of the most dormant Millenium Development Goals, and fundamentally changes the role played by international aid groups.

Secondary Department: 

Curated news and insights about innovative, market-driven solutions to poverty explored through news, commentary and discussion.

Learn more »

Global Envision newsletter