China May Succeed Where the West Failed -- In Africa

China's attitude towards Africa was apparent in a slogan at a summit on Africa in Beijing. Photo: <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/stephenrwalli/295101176/">stephenrwalli (flickr)</a>
China's attitude towards Africa was apparent in a slogan at a summit on Africa in Beijing. Photo: stephenrwalli (flickr)

Deborah Brautigan doesn't argue with critics who call China's interest in Africa self-serving. But she may be one of the first American academics to declare that China's deeds will be good for Africa, too.

It's an argument she expands in The Dragon's Gift, a new book analyzing the development of China's Africa policies over the last few decades.

Brautigan asserts that China's investments are integrating African countries into the global economy more quickly because, unlike Western countries, the nation invests in an array of industries. In Angola, for example, China has built roads, schools, hospitals, and irrigation systems in the country's interior — even though its oil wealth is far offshore. Brautigan also cites a telling remark by a Nigerian diplomat: "The Chinese are trying to get involved in every sector of our economy. If you look at the West, it's oil, oil, oil and nothing else."

And on a continent rife with corruption, China's style of development actually leaves less room for embezzlement than does the World Bank model, points out a book review in The Morning Star. Rather than funneling money through potentially corrupt government officials, China pays Chinese companies to head up infrastructure projects.

Brautigan acknowledges that China's behavior in Africa is sometimes far from saintly. Some have complained that Chinese companies do not respect local labor laws, as happened at a mine in Congo, and others worry that Chinese companies will have a negative environmental impact on the continent.

While not negligible, Brautigan sees these violations as small in comparison to what China's investments could mean for Africa, and in comparison to the failed promise of other foreign aid there. As an AidWatchers review noted, this "book seeks to compare Chinese aid to Western aid as it really is, not as we wish it were."

Comments

in Portland, OR

I'm glad you wrote this

I'm glad you wrote this article, Sarah, because it's a much needed contrast to the general consensus (i.e., that China is exploiting African countries).

China's involvement in Africa is an important topic of debate that has been obscured by uninformed assumptions. Many people distrust China and wonder what its "real" motives are for so much investment. However, I think the AidWatchers article really hit the crux of the matter with the following statement: "...like all donors, US definitely included, China is motivated to give aid by a mix of political, commercial, and social/ideological factors." All countries are essentially motivated by self-interest. It just may be that China is more unabashed about its intentions.

Meanwhile, other people point to China's own development, rife with problems with corruption and destruction of the environment. Although these are legitimate concerns, I think these claims miss the bottom line.

According the UNDP, China has successfully halved the number of people living in poverty from 85 million in 1990. Although the income gap between the rich and the poor has widened, the poor are at a much better position than ever before.

Though China's investment may not be perfect, it is certainly better than allowing African states to languish in economic stagnancy. Until someone comes along with a better plan, it's Africa's best option--so why not let them go ahead?

Driving economic development

I am glad that there is Chinese aid in the equation, alongside the lucrative deals and grabs for resource commodities. I agree, Olivia, that China is perhaps more unabashed about their intentions than other donors.

Motivations aside, the reality is the Chinese flag is flying across the continent. There are more Chinese living in Nigeria than there were Britons during the height of the empire. New embassies and a new Chinese elite are emerging, putting greater resource demands on areas with booming populations. The West can be worried for our sake, for the environment's sake....but for the sub-Saharan Africans' sake? I'm looking forward to reading Brautigan's book. The Chinese multi-sector investment strategy is underway, and it seems to be a promising driver of economic development.

Interesting article

China is definitely approaching development of infrastructure in Africa in a way that contrasts with our approach, but it may not be more effective in the long run. Working outside of corrupt African governments certainly helps funding get directly to the people and places it is most needed. It will be interesting, though, to see if using only Chinese contractors will, in the end, actually help African nations wean their way off of foreign aid and become more self sustaining. Foreign aid of any type may not actually benefit African nations as they attempt to develop, so I am definitely interested in reading Brautigan's book.

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options


Stories We're Watching

Putin Extends Ban on Russian Grain Exports

International Herald Tribune - Thu, 09/02/2010 - 23:01
Prime Minister Vladimir V. Putin announced Thursday that Russia’s ban on grain exports would be extended well into next year because of continued uncertainty over production.

Afghans Pull Money From Weakened Bank

New York Times - Thu, 09/02/2010 - 22:08
One of the principal owners of the bank predicted a “revolution” in the financial system unless efforts were made to help stabilize the bank.

Nations Meet on Climate Cash, UN Sees Long Haul

Reuters - Thu, 09/02/2010 - 11:36
About 45 nations met on Thursday to seek ways to raise billions of dollars in aid to help the poor combat climate change as the United Nations warned them of a long haul to slow global warming.

As India Looks at Cutting Carbon, a Wind Farm Scandal

Christian Science Monitor - Tue, 08/31/2010 - 07:43
The world’s third-largest maker of wind turbines is accused again of cheating tribal people to set up wind farms in India, highlighting the pitfalls of carbon-offset projects in developing countries.

Iraqis Fear Bleak Future

Al Jazeera - Tue, 08/31/2010 - 04:57
Concern among many is the failure of Iraqi politicians to form a government six months after elections.

Recent comments

  • "This raises an interesting point about statistics. Often times they can be used to paint a picture that looks good at a..."
    by Christopher Sharp
    on China Takes Number Two Spot
  • "Very well written, and thought provoking. Humanitarian aid is most definitely a positive contribution to developing..."
    by Christopher Sharp
    on To Aid or Trade?
  • "Lower scale farmers can't afford higher cost for electricity to maintain the normal stoves and sawdust stove is the best..."
  • "Wow, Maya! I'm impressed with your level of dedication to this topic. You raised a very good point that the..."
    by Lyndsey Romick
    on Building Cities by New Rules
  • "So, I contacted Mr. Romer to ask my question about his choice of promoting charter cities rather than SEZs and this is..."

Countries

An initiative of Mercy Corps
“You must be the change
you wish to see in the world”
Mahatma Gandhi
Learn more about Mercy Corps >

Efficiency

Over the last five years, more than 89% of Mercy Corps' resources have been allocated directly to programs

Excellence

America's premier charity evaluator gives Mercy Corps four stars in organizational efficiency. Click here to learn more.

High Value

Every dollar you donate to Mercy Corps helps us secure $11.16 in donated food and other critical supplies.

Mercy Corps — Dept. W — 45 SW Ankeny — Portland, OR 97204
All original content Copyright © 2009 Mercy Corps. Quoted and linked content is property of the creator(s). Mercy Corps will not sell, rent or trade your personal information.