Beyond Savings and Loans

Women in SHGs spoke about bright futures for their daughters and want to work towards increasing the educational opportunities that are available to them in their village of Karauli. Photo: Carmina Rinker
Women in SHGs spoke about bright futures for their daughters and want to work towards increasing the educational opportunities that are available to them in their village of Karauli. Photo: Carmina Rinker

I recently returned from a study and service-leaning trip in India. While was there I traveled with a small group of Portland State University students and faculty, visiting several grassroots NGOs working with women's microfinance groups in Maharashtra. In this part of the world, Self Help Groups (SHGs) go beyond lending, they also are tackling issues like domestic violence, health care and politics.

Sitting in matching blue Saris with gold trim, about ten women are seated inside a small room passing chai and biscuits to their foreign guests. They discuss their business ventures, their children, and ask our small group of American students questions about our lives in the United States. One mother is beaming with pride as she coaches her small daughter to recite a poem, "Airplane, Airplane" in perfect English.

With the growing popularity of Kiva.org and the heightened awareness of the Grameen bank, many of us Westerners are just now discovering the impact of microfinance programs as a tool of poverty alleviation and women's empowerment. But for hundreds of women in the village of Karauli in Maharashtra, India, this is old news. Women here have been active in Self Help Groups (SHGs) for close to a decade or more, and in this time their participation has extended far beyond the collective savings, loans, that are the most basic elements of microfinance schemes. Self Help Groups are groups of women who come together to save money collectively, and from their collective savings they can take individual loans in order to make repairs on their house, buy goods for their microenterprises, send their children to school, or for whatever purpose they need it for. In addition the SHGs act as a social support network through which the women can come together to address individual and broader social issues such as domestic violence, women's health, and sanitation issues in their communities. SHGs differ from Joint Liability Groups (as used by the Grameen Bank), in that they usually have about 10-20 members whose loans come directly from the group's own savings instead of from a bank or Microfinance Institution. In order to mobilize more credit for larger loans, groups of SHGs often come together to form a Federation.

While visiting two of thirty or so SHGs that are active in Karauli, a village with a population of around 7,000, women spoke about taking out loans to send their children to the university in the nearby city of Pune, large entrepreneurial ventures such as opening a hotel, and accumulating a collective group savings of Rs 8.5 lakhs (equivalent to about 17,000 US dollars). Yet beyond the financial benefit that these women enjoy through their participation in the SHGs (as well as the pride and confidence that goes along with it), the women also spoke about other changes that extend beyond their individual and family levels, and to their greater communities. This ranges from launching village clean-ups to rid their communities of litter, participating in village politics (panchayats). The women who have adopted the blue sari uniform to wear to their monthly meetings organized a 100 Woman March to the Office of the Minister of Irrigation of Maharastra to raise their concerns over water availability and sanitation. This group has been together for over eight years, and during that time every women in the room — about half of their 20 members — has served a term as SHG leader. They explain that before joining the SHG they had little to no interaction and involvement in public spaces, yet with the leadership skills they have now developed as well as the mutual trust and social capital that has been built through the group, they now feel less inhibited to be active in the public domain.

These SHGs have been organized and facilitated by the NGO Chaitanya, based in the nearby town of Rajgurunagar. Chaitanya came into existence in 1993, and began by incorporating microfinance programs using SHGs in rural areas. Today they have expanded to include many other programs that address issues of livelihood and agriculture, legal needs, education, and health of the rural poor.

Comments

Overcoming Gender Inequality: Beyond Microfinance

I believe that overcoming gender inequality is a top priority and one of the most pressing issues in developing nations worldwide – more efforts are needed to help women build growth businesses that can generate prosperity.

Over a year after its launch, our Women Mean Business program in Uganda is making amazing progress in empowering women to succeed by going beyond microfinance and expanding the range of economic opportunities available to them through training in management skills and business plan development. The ultimate goal is to have these growing businesses spur growth in the economy, essentially improving the lives of women’s families and communities.

-Simon Winter, TechnoServe

in Portland, OR

SHGs seem like a really

SHGs seem like a really innovative idea. As micro entrepreneurs, especially women, often have little credit history or collateral, it would seem like this set up would be more efficient then banks or even microloan outfits. A debtor's peers and neighbors are in the best position to make decisions with the fund's (the community's) best interest in mind, and for the loanee, making good on the payments is a matter of interest for their community, not just a bank. All have vested interest enabling the success of everyone else.
I was really happy to read that this has such a positive social impact on the women as well, encouraging political participation as well as upward mobility. I'm curious if this system is as successful in bigger more urban areas, where the social dynamic is different and there are a lot of transplants.

Loans

I have heard about these small business loans being used in many parts of the world to help individuals start businesses in their villages. It is good to read about the success that comes from these efforts.

In addition to the success, it looks like many other fine services are growing in these communities. Help with domestic abuse, womens health, and various social issues offer more hope for these people. Let's all pray for continued progress.casino en ligne

in oregon

It is exciting to hear that

It is exciting to hear that these women are taking their financial well being into their own hands by investing in the Self Help Groups. Not only will they continue to benefit from the opportunities that are presented them through the SHG's, but the generations that follow also benefit in the form of financially savvy parents, higher education that may not have been available otherwise, gaining leadership skills,etc...

The credit union movement began in the same way in the mid 1800's, as a non profit financial cooperative which is owned and democratically controlled by its members.
Credit unions were and still are used as a means of attaining affordable financial assistance.

Wow SHGs seem like a really

Wow SHGs seem like a really innovative idea, it's true. It is exciting to hear that these women are taking their financial well being into their own hands by investing in the Self Help Groups !

in France

Thank you for this

Thank you for this interesting post, even if I didn't understand everything, because I'm french.
I understand the main idea and I think the intentions are good.

in cairo

Thanks

Thank you for this interesting post.

Thanks

This is a great post. Thanks for sharing.

Excellent information

Thank you for this interesting post, this is really worth reading.

Microfinance is amazing.

Microfinance is amazing. Allowing millions to send their children to university in order to "break the chain" and give these families a brighter future. Great article, thanks.
bonus casino

nice article thank you very

nice article thank you very much

mutuelle

in Chapel Hill, NC

Thoughts on microfinance

Having spent this past summer working for a microfinance institute (MFI) and studying microfinance, I am excited with the progress Kiva.com and the recent attention to this relatively new tool of microfinance for economic development. One aspect of microfinance that I think is often overlooked stems from its diffused and pervasive structure. While microcredit has been the key instrument in this movement to fight poverty, microfinance is more than a particular product or service—it’s a medium to the poorest. For the microfinance revolution to continue expanding and innovating, it is critical that MFIs perceive themselves as platforms for change and not merely distributers of a product. The potential uses of this medium are extremely broad and I anticipate seeing more types of services such as Grameen Telecom in the future.
One caveat I do have for microfinance concerns their temptation to become sustainable quickly. Work can be done on broadening the target portfolio for most MFIs. Pressure to work with a safe portfolio may lead to quicker sustainability but may also compromise the original goal of eradicating poverty. In my experience and reading I believe that most MFIs right now are only making a substantial difference among a relatively small portion of the poor: preexisting entrepreneurs struggling to stay afloat. It will be hard transitioning from a primary survival resource for this small group to becoming a facilitator of new small businesses with a population that is even riskier, less educated, and more impoverished. Nevertheless, this transition is necessary for tackling poverty head on.

P.S.: A friend and former coworker of mine through microfinance is starting up an organization similar to Kiva.com. If you care to find out more about microfinance and look to get involved with a social-business start up please check out http://beta.dvelo.org/index.php.

There is a similar initiative

There is a similar initiative in Laos which I have seen first hand as so much more effective than supplying constant aid to the families affected. With the loans they can afford to buy livestock, send their children to school and make a better future for themselves. What a fantastic solution to a problem that does not need to exist.
casino gratuit

Empowerment

This is such an amazing project. I think the biggest benefit of this is that the people who are helped are also empowered to continue making things better for themselves. Its not just a matter of helping someone, its giving them the tools to help themselves, and in turn, help others.
casino gratuit

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <blockquote>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Stories We're Watching

As Africa's consumers rise, so does inequality

Yale Global Online - Fri, 02/03/2012 - 10:17
Kenya struggles to spread the wealth from rapid growth.

U.N. says famine in Somalia over, but risks remain

New York Times - Fri, 02/03/2012 - 22:56
A bumper harvest and a surge in emergency food aid have ended a famine in Somalia that killed tens of thousands of people, the United Nations said on Friday.

Looking forward, Fiji turns to its canoeing past

International Herald Tribune - Fri, 02/03/2012 - 23:27
The traditional canoe is at the center of several projects aimed at reducing Fiji’s energy consumption, providing islanders with cheaper transport, keeping local traditions alive, and giving a boost to tourism.

The 6 questions that lead to new innovations

Fast Company's Co.Exist - Fri, 02/03/2012 - 07:00
It is often said that innovation is at the core of sustainability, but turning that abstract idea into action isn’t always easy. How do true innovators actually make the leap from status quo to full-on disruption?

Brazil deepens strategic cooperation with Cuba

Inter Press Service - development - Mon, 02/06/2012 - 12:11
Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff's visit to Cuba served to further strengthen bilateral relations between the two countries, leverage the South American giant's investments in the Caribbean island, and deepen political ties.

Recent comments

Countries

An initiative of Mercy Corps
“You must be the change
you wish to see in the world”
Mahatma Gandhi
Learn more about Mercy Corps >

Efficiency

Over the last five years, more than 89% of Mercy Corps' resources have been allocated directly to programs

Excellence

America's premier charity evaluator gives Mercy Corps four stars in organizational efficiency. Click here to learn more.

High Value

Every dollar you donate to Mercy Corps helps us secure $11.16 in donated food and other critical supplies.

Mercy Corps — Dept. W — 45 SW Ankeny — Portland, OR 97204
All original content Copyright © 2009 Mercy Corps. Quoted and linked content is property of the creator(s). Mercy Corps will not sell, rent or trade your personal information.