Economics as a Catalyst for Peace
The last divided capital city in the world is Nicosia, Cyprus. Armed soldiers line each side of a buffer zone, with Greeks living on one side and Turks on the other. The island has been at the center of a decades-long dispute between Greece and Turkey that remains one of Europe’s biggest headaches.
But Cyprus today might be closer to a solution than ever before. When Turkish forces invaded and divided the island in 1974, the two communities were separated: Turks in the north and Greeks in the south.
New, more moderate leadership in both the north and south makes unification and compromise more likely. And people in the north — whose standard of living lags far behind their southern counterparts — may be ready for the economic benefits their neighbors are enjoying.
The south has grown far wealthier than the north since 2004, when Cyprus entered the European Union. (Cyprus in this case refers to all land not part of the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus, often referred to as the TRNC, the northern third of the country governed by Turkey.) Cyprus adopted the euro, began receiving EU subsidies, and started trading freely within the European market. By contrast, the north has been limited to trade with Turkey, the only country that recognizes it as a legitimate state. Its GDP is around one third of the south’s.
The effects of isolation are seen clearly in north Nicosia, where homes are missing shutters, streets are full of potholes, and many wear tattered clothing. By contrast, walk 10 minutes south and just beyond the buffer zone you’ll see gourmet restaurants, chic clothing stores, and well-to-do European vacationers enjoying their afternoon frappé.
Though the gap in living standards has worsened since 2004, it could be this very disparity which ultimately brings the island together. When he took office in 2005, TRNC President Mehmet Ali Talat said finding a solution to “the Cyprus problem” would be his main initiative. Since then he has started negotiations with the south along with key international players, and has recently addressed the Council of Europe’s PACE General Assembly – the first northern Cypriot President to do so.
If the island achieves unification, both sides have much to gain. In addition to reducing poverty in the north by way of its integration into the EU, many Greek refugees who fled south in 1974 may finally have the opportunity to return home. Furthermore, the world’s last divided capital city may become whole.


Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Reddit
Facebook
Google
Yahoo
Comments
Divided Cyprus.
It is apparent from the author's report that he/she knows absolutely nothing about the history of Cyprus. Until 1960, Cyprus was a British Protectorate and had been for more than 100 years. Eoka created chaos - fighting and killing British troops until 1960. Thereafter it was jointly governed by the Greek speaking and Turkish speaking peoples. In 1974 the Turkish forces from the Turkish mainland went to the aid of the Turkish speaking population to prevent further genocide being conducted by the Greek speaking peoples at the instigation of Eoka 2 - who were under the influence of the Greek mainland generals who at that time were busy ousting the Greek King and all the Greek Royal Family. It was decided that the Turkish speaking peoples would live in the North of the island and the Greek speaking peoples in the South of the Island. There is a 'buffer' zone between the two area - NEITHER ZONE IS PATROLLED BY MILITARY FROM EITHER THE NORTH OR THE SOUTH BUT BY PERSONNEL FROM THE UNITED NATIONS. The UN personnel do not patrol in the sense that they 'keep the peace'. Bree Freeman's report gives the impression that the area is similar to that pertaining when the Berlin Wall was in existance. There was a referendum in 2004, held in the North and the South on the same day to determine whether both peoples should join the EU - the North voted affimatively, the South voted against. Since September this year there have been ongoing talks between the Prime Ministers of both North and SouthCyprus to find a way forward such that both peoples become self-governing but that the Turkish speaking peoples of Cyprus can be accepted by the rest of the EU and the world that they legitimately live (and have legitimately lived for hundreds of years) on the island of Cyprus. Please, be very careful what you write - your one sided and inept report could do much harm to the ongoing talks and deliberations. There is no bar to anyone from the North visiting the South, similarly vice versa. One more point, until 1974 Turkish speaking and Greek speaking peoples lived all over the island - villages were 'mixed' - it was only after the genocide of 1974 (when incidentally they tried to murder Archbishop Makarios) that it became apparent that for the time being it was necessary to prevent further troubles that the two peoples should live separately. There are many areas in the South which once were owned by Turkish people - Larnaca airport being but one. I might add that I am neither Turkish nor Cypriot but British.
Divided Cyprus.
One further point to my last submission. It is a huge insult to the Turkish people in the North to say that they wear 'tattered clothes' - this is simply not true. It is such an insult that I think the author should issue an apology. There are some roads which are potholed, there are some houses which are shutterless (many of such properties are owned by people now living in the South). There are many first class, world class hotels, restaurants and privately owned houses in the North. Such gross incorrect nasty exaggeration from Bree Freeman is nothing more than complete and utter tosh.
Divided Cyprus
I have spent an extensive amount of time studying this conflict at home and in Cyprus itself. This past summer I was able to speak with the incumbent TRNC president, Mehmet Ali Talat, as well as the former president of the south, Glafkos Clerides. I’m fully aware of the history of this island and the MANY events on both sides that have led up to the current situation today.
Although EOKA, driven by the enosis movement, was a nationalist organization that was the cause of many problems in Cyprus there are other variables that have played a part in creating the current stalemate. Takism, in response to enosis, should also be mentioned in this case which did much more in creating a division between the two communities than bringing them together. However, My objective in this post was not to point fingers and place historical blame on those that I believed caused this problem, but to focus more on its future and the constructive measures currently taking place.
In describing the economic disparity of the two communities my goal was not to insult the Turkish Cypriot people but to point out the unfair conditions in which they live. The ‘first class’ restaurants and hotels that you speak of are almost entirely enjoyed by wealthy European vacationers and not the Turkish Cypriots themselves. Many vacationers carelessly play on the beautiful beaches of Kyrenia now lined with hotels and know nothing about the massacre that took place there just decades before. Many Turkish Cypriots have been welcoming of these tourists as it is one of their few sources of income. Villages that are not occupied by tourists is where you see this true disparity. I apologize if I came across insulting in any way but these conditions aren’t being spoken about enough. I have met with many NGO’s working in the north and south and can assure you that there are many problems that are not openly spoken about for fear of discouraging wealthy vacationers of coming to spend their money. The island has few resources and is largely dependent on income from tourism.
There are several crossing points in Nicosia, none of which are the same. There are however, many armed soldiers in this area in addition to the UN presence-- especially those from Turkey. This is extremely important to note as the presence of Turkish soldiers in Cyprus is one of the many topics being discussed in the negotiations and a very controversial issue.
What I’m trying to point out is that the talks that are happening now are positive and Talat has gone far beyond his predecessor in trying to create a solution. Christoifias, whose predecessor Papadopoulos refused to meet with the TRNC president and advocated for the rejection of the 2004 referendum by the south, has showed a willingness to compromise that hasn’t been seen for some time.
The reality is, the TRNC is currently unrecognized by anyone other than Turkey. For the island to unite and have the whole territory in the EU would raise the standard of living for Turkish Cypriots significantly. Right now the isolation of the TRNC is just increasing its dependency on Turkey, there is little they can do to be self sustained when they cannot even trade with any other country. There is talk of the island remaining bizonal and bicommunal and the power sharing between Greek and Turkish Cypriots is among topics being negotiated. I am fully aware that the two ethnic groups, Greeks and Turks, have long lived in peace in this island and my point of this article was to give hope that they can again. I think the EU can play a positive role in this process as they are strong advocates of human rights which is extremely important for the Turkish community given their historical place in this conflict. Though history is tremendously important when discussing this conflict, looking forward and acknowledging the progress being made is key to a solution.
Economics and conflict in Cyprus
Bree pointed out, "That many problems are not openly
spoken about for fear of discouraging wealthy
vacationers of coming to spend their money." This is
key to the disagreement in the above commentaries.
It's hard to understand the economic situation of a
region in conflict, until the people of the region are
given a safe place to discuss their economic
situation. Without this security to share their story,
the are simply being silenced. This is a fundamental
aspect of oppression, and only reiterates what both of
the above authors addressed, in their own styles, that
collaboration and resolution would benefit all of
Cyprus.
On a positive note, leaders of both regions are
continuing to work, in a forward moving direction. The
New York Times reports, "Talks to reunify Cyprus
resumed Monday as Turkish and Greek leaders met in
Nicosia for the sixth time in a month, where they
continued to focus on issues of power-sharing in a
possible federation."
Post new comment
More information about formatting options